|
Chapter 19
Terry Baker |
||||||||||||
| Introduction America’s veterans have been plagued with many health issues since the founding of this country. Hepatitis has long been associated with U.S. military service. Military training and combat present many opportunities for transmission of viral hepatitis through blood-to-blood contact. Field bleeding, surgery, transfusions, and exposure to blood by military medics and surgeons all constitute high risks. During World War I, thousands of American GI’s were stricken with hepatitis A. To this day, service men and women still become ill with hepatitis A, B, and C (formerly known as non-A, non-B hepatitis). Since the identification of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) in 1989, physicians and Veterans Administration (VA) officials have seen large numbers of infection among veterans. Veterans appear to have unusually high rates of hepatitis C. While the prevalence of hepatitis C in the general population is approximately 1.8%, various studies in VA facilities have shown hepatitis C virus (HCV) prevalence rates between 10-20% among veterans.1 Veterans of foreign combat appear to be at the highest risk for infectious hepatitis. All major engagements of the last 60 years, World War II, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War, were associated with high rates of infectious hepatitis. Viral hepatitis was viewed as a single disease in the early years, and most treatment and documentation of it were for the acute forms of the disease. Veterans and Hepatitis C Timeline
Veterans' Hepatitis C Survey Bruskin-Goldring Research conducted a national survey commissioned by VATA of 504 veterans in 1999. Ages of those surveyed ranged from 40-60, with a mean age of 49. Following are some of the highlights from that survey.
These findings clearly indicate there is a need for HCV education. Veterans must be informed of their risk for hepatitis C, and about the seriousness of the disease. The Incidence of Hepatitis C Among America's Military Veterans Veterans’ advocates have grown increasingly concerned in recent years about the incidence of hepatitis C among military veterans. Several studies have suggested veterans may be at higher risk than the general public. According to testimony given before the U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations, Subcommittee on Veterans’ Affairs, 69,000 veterans in VA facilities have tested HCV positive since 1999.5 Studies at the VA Medical Centers (VAMC) in Washington D.C. and San Francisco found the prevalence of HCV positive inpatients was 20% and 10%, respectively.1 One of these studies also found 52% of patients requiring liver transplant were HCV positive.1 In 1998, a national tracking system analyzed the findings from 95,000 hepatitis C screening tests performed in the VA system.4 Of those who tested positive:
Veterans of the Vietnam War: The Largest Military Population Most At Risk Of the 8.1 million surviving veterans of the Vietnam War, 3.2 million had active duty in Asia between 1964 and 1973.6 It is conservatively estimated that 10% of these Asian theater veterans are now infected with HCV.1 Modes of Transmission of HCV in the Asian Theater of the Vietnam War There are a number of HCV risk factors for veterans who were in Asia during the Vietnam War, many related to the high prevalence of HCV in southeast Asian countries. It is estimated that 5-8% of the Vietnamese population is infected with HCV.7 Transfusions Transfusion of blood or blood products before 1992 is a known risk factor for HCV infection. Prior to 1992, there were no accurate HCV screening tests to ensure the safety of the blood supply with respect to HCV.3 Three hundred thousand Americans were wounded and 153,329 were hospitalized during the Vietnam War. Between March 1967 and June 1969, 364,900 Americans in Vietnam received blood transfusions.2 It is estimated that a minimum of 10% of those transfused received HCV infected blood.8 Medical Contact Surgeons, nurses, medics, helicopter crews, and others involved in the evacuation and treatment of the wounded from Vietnam were also placed at risk for HCV infection because of their blood exposure. An estimated 41.1% of all soldiers deployed to Vietnam, approximately 2.1 million veterans, were involved in combat. Many soldiers assisted the more than 300,000 wounded. Medical personnel on hospital ships were also placed at risk via their exposure to wounded soldiers from the Vietnam theater.9 Tattoos Unclean needles that pierce the skin can transmit HCV. While transmission of HCV by tattooing has not been fully documented in the U.S., it has been documented elsewhere.10 An estimated 34% of active-duty military personnel have tattoos (personal communication, Capt. John Mateczun, Principal Director, Clinical Affairs, Office of Health Affairs, Department of Defense). Many of these tattoos were and continue to be acquired in countries where sanitation is often substandard. Sexual Contact Although sexual transmission of HCV occurs, it is believed to be relatively uncommon. Nevertheless, a portion of those infected with HCV during the Vietnam War were probably infected through sexual contact with Vietnamese nationals. Recreational Drug Use Sharing drug paraphernalia is currently the most common cause of newly acquired HCV infections. This was also a risk factor during the Vietnam War. A study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on the health status of Vietnam veterans found 3% had used “hard drugs,” including amphetamines, barbiturates, cocaine, heroin, psychedelics, phencyclidine and methaqualone.11 VA Monitoring of HCV-Infected Veterans The Department of Veterans Affairs has noted a decided increase in the number of HCV cases diagnosed over the past several years. There were 6,600 HCV cases reported in the VA system in 1991. By 1994, this number had increased to 18,854. Over the next four years, the annual number of newly identified cases increased steadily to 20,203 in 1995, 21,424 in 1996, 24,850 in 1997, and 29,799 in 1998. Since March 1999, over 69,000 additional cases have been identified. VA officials expect this number to continue to increase substantially.12 Testing of veterans outside the VA medical system has confirmed the high HCV prevalence in this population. A 1998 screening program that tested 200 apparently healthy leaders of the Vietnam Veterans of America found 9% of those tested were infected with HCV. 13 A more recent screening at a Vietnam Veterans’ stand down found 36% of those screened tested positive for HCV. Although these numbers are preliminary, they all point to the fact that veterans have consistently high rates of HCV infection of at least 10%, more than five times the prevalence rate in the general population. In June 1998, the VA issued new HCV screening guidelines for veterans entering VA facilities who have one or more of ten specified risk factors. The VA has also established two Centers of Excellence located at the VA medical centers in Miami and San Francisco. These centers coordinate treatment and research efforts, and develop educational programs for patients and their families. Health care providers who specialize in HCV and patient counselors are also located at these centers. These centers established the current guidelines for VA clinicians who treat patients with hepatitis C. The VA expects the new screening guidelines will dramatically increase the number of VA patients identified with hepatitis C. The demand for HCV related services is expected to rise proportionately. The screening guidelines indicate that any veteran who requests HCV testing should be tested regardless of his or her risk factors. In December 1999, the VA adopted treatment guidelines for HCV infection. The guidelines recommend that eligible veterans be given the very best medical care, including the most recently approved treatment. Of course, only veterans who are income eligible or service connected for HCV can receive treatment through a VA medical center. Despite the treatment guidelines, veterans report problems obtaining care due to constraints put on HCV health care at the Veterans Integrated Service Network (VISN) level. The one fact on which we can all probably agree is that hepatitis C among military veterans is an overwhelming problem for the Veterans Administration. The Need for a Service Connection to HCV to Receive Treatment Through a VA Facility As a result of the reorganization of the VAMC system, all veterans have been put into one of seven categories according to his or her medical priority. Currently all veterans, regardless of their category, receive medical treatment when they come to a VAMC. However, unless they are 100% service connected, a copayment is required for all services and medicines. It is critically important for veterans with HCV to be granted presumptive service connection to the disease so they can be treated. However, veterans infected with HCV during their military service are generally unable to establish the necessary service connection. A lack of knowledge about hepatitis C and how it is contracted, a historic lack of a reliable screening test, and the prolonged, often asymptomatic course of disease progression all conspire to make it extremely difficult to prove that infection was acquired during military service. Without a service connection to HCV, most veterans are unable to meet the standard of proof necessary to show that they contracted HCV during their military service. As the VA’s budget continues to shrink, we fear that veterans without a service connected injury (including veterans with HCV) will be turned away from VAMCs. Currently, Vietnam veterans are the military group most significantly affected by hepatitis C. Many veterans who contracted HCV in Vietnam 25-30 years ago are only now exhibiting symptoms of liver disease. When they were first infected, HCV had not been distinguished from other forms of hepatitis. In 85% of the cases, there would have been no acute symptoms at the time of infection. Detecting HCV infection at the time of discharge was also impossible. Many of today’s HCV infected veterans were discharged from the military before tests for hepatitis C existed. Even today, when there are reliable tests for hepatitis C, the military does not conduct HCV testing as part of the discharge physical. HCV infected veterans who were treated for acute hepatitis during their military service and who now appear before the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (BVA) to establish service connection are most often denied because they cannot prove their current HCV infection is related to their prior acute hepatitis. The Board often rejects a claim for service connection because the veteran’s medical record does not show the presence of HCV at the time of discharge. In fact, in the review of all 1,599 cases of chronic hepatitis brought before the BVA between 1994 and 1996, only 37 resulted in approval of a service-related disability rating for hepatitis.14 Making a service connection to HCV will enable veterans to be tested for hepatitis C, and those who are positive and desire treatment to obtain treatment through the VA system. It will also enable veterans who progress to advanced liver disease to get adequate treatment through the VA. Establishing A Service Connection to Hepatitis C To establish a successful claim for military service connected disability from hepatitis C, you must meet the following requirements.
Successful claims often include a private physician’s (often a gastroenterologist or hepatologist) letter indicating that, in his or her opinion, your hepatitis C is a direct result of your military service. You should be aware that activities that show “willful misconduct” could disqualify you from compensation. These activities include body piercing, tattoos, and/or use of injected recreational drugs, snorted cocaine, and other drug use. If you are a veteran diagnosed with hepatitis C, the first thing you should do is to find a qualified Veterans Service Officer to assist you in filing a claim for a service connection to hepatitis C. Most Service Officers work for a county or state veteran’s service. From the Veterans Aimed Toward Awareness’s internet site at www.vetsaware.org, you can link to the Vietnam Veterans of America site. From there, go to “Benefits” and then to “Service Representatives” to select a representative from your state. Service representatives know the laws, rules of filing, and the paperwork you will need to complete for a claim. Summary Veterans’ advocates have made it a priority to see that service men and women are tested for hepatitis C. We are working to ensure that treatment is affordable, and that information will be available for those who need it. It is my heartfelt commitment to work to see these goals accomplished.
|